The ecotoxicity of zinc and zinc‐containing substances in soil with consideration of metal‐moiety approaches and organometal complexes

• Published in: Environmental toxicology and chemistry 2017-12, Vol.36 (12), p.3324-3332
• Main Authors: Ritchie, Ellyn, Boyd, Patrick, Lawson‐Halasz, Annamaria, Hawari, Jalal, Saucier, Stacey, Scroggins, Richard, Princz, Juliska
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Animals; Arthropods - drug effects; Canada; Chlorides - chemistry; Chlorides - toxicity; Coordination Complexes - chemistry; Coordination Complexes - toxicity; Coordination compounds; Elymus - drug effects; Metal complexes; Metal concentrations; Metal ions; Metal toxicity; Metals; Oligochaeta - drug effects; Plants; Risk management; Salts; Sandy soils; Soil - chemistry; Soil ecotoxicology; Soil invertebrates; Soil Pollutants - chemistry; Soil Pollutants - toxicity; Soils; Structure-Activity Relationship; Subgroups; Toxicity; Toxicity testing; Trifolium - drug effects; Zinc; Zinc - chemistry; Zinc - toxicity; Zinc Compounds - chemistry; Zinc Compounds - toxicity; Zinc Oxide - chemistry; Zinc Oxide - toxicity
• ISSN: 0730-7268; 1552-8618
• DOI: 10.1002/etc.3910

Within Canada, screening‐level assessments for chemical substances are required to determine whether the substances pose a risk to human health and/or the environment, and as appropriate, risk management strategies. In response to the volume of metal and metal‐containing substances, process efficiencies were introduced using a metal‐moiety approach, whereby substances that contain a common metal moiety are assessed simultaneously as a group, with the moiety of concern consisting of the metal ion. However, for certain subgroups, such as organometals or organic metal salts, the organic moiety or parent substance may be of concern, rather than simply the metal ion. To further investigate the need for such additional consideration, certain substances were evaluated: zinc (Zn)‐containing inorganic (Zn chloride [ZnCl2] and Zn oxide) and organic (organometal: Zn diethyldithiocarbamate [Zn(DDC)2] and organic metal salts (Zn stearate [ZnSt] and 4‐chloro‐2‐nitrobenzenediazonium tetrachlorozincate [BCNZ]). The toxicity of the substances were assessed using plant (Trifolium pratense and Elymus lanceolatus) and soil invertebrate (Folsomia candida and Eisenia andrei) tests in a sandy soil. Effect measures were determined based on total metal and total parent analyses (for organic substances). In general, the inorganic Zn substances were less toxic than the organometals and organic metal salts, with 50% effective concentrations ranging from 11 to >5194 mg Zn kg−1 dry soil. The data demonstrate the necessity for alternate approaches in the assessment of organo–metal complexes, with the organic moieties or parent substances warranting consideration rather than the metal ion alone. In this instance, the organometals and organic metal salts were significantly more toxic than other test substances despite their low total Zn content. Environ Toxicol Chem 2017;36:3324–3332. © 2017 Crown in the Right of Canada. Published by Wiley Periodicals Inc. on behalf of SETAC.