Tools for adaptive governance for complex social-ecological systems: a review of role-playing-games as serious games at the community-policy interface

• Published in: Environmental research letters 2019-11, Vol.14 (11), p.113002
• Main Authors: Edwards, Peter, Sharma-Wallace, Lisa, Wreford, Anita, Holt, Lania, Cradock-Henry, Nicholas A, Flood, Stephen, Velarde, Sandra J
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: adaptive governance; Computer & video games; Decision making; developed countries; Educational software; Evaluation; Fisheries; Freshwater fish; Games; Literature reviews; Multiple criterion; Natural resource management; Natural resources; New Zealand; Resource management; Role playing; role-playing games; serious games; Social-ecological systems
• ISSN: 1748-9326; 1748-9326
• DOI: 10.1088/1748-9326/ab4036

The management of natural resources-from forests to fisheries to freshwater-is becoming increasingly complex and requires new tools and processes for engaging with individuals, communities, and decision-makers. Policy makers and practitioners have begun using serious games (SGs) (those used for purposes other than entertainment) to overcome some of the complex challenges of governing resources in social-ecological systems. This paper uses a systematic literature review methodology to assess role-playing SGs for natural resource management. Fifty-two articles from the role-playing game (RPG) subset of SGs are identified, synthesised and analysed using a multi-criteria evaluation framework. First, we explore three theoretical and conceptual elements of games: principles of RPGs, functions of games, and (practical) game characteristics. We evaluate game elements, including game design, adherence to reality and the degree to which games integrate elements of participatory-and action research. These dimensions of RPGs are then analysed and discussed. Particular attention is paid to the value and application of RPGs to address complex problems with interacting environmental, social, cultural and economic challenges, and the extent to which they can inform adaptive governance solutions. Results show that RPGs can be a valuable tool at different levels; however, we also identify important gaps in the current state of knowledge, in particular, related to bridging community-and higher-level decision-making scales through RPGs.