Uncertainty Characterization of Ground‐Based, Satellite, and Reanalysis Snow Depth Products Using Extended Triple Collocation

• Published in: Water resources research 2022-04, Vol.58 (4), p.n/a
• Main Authors: Qiao, Dejing, Li, Zhen, Zeng, Jiangyuan, Liang, Shuang, McColl, Kaighin A., Bi, Haiyun, Zhou, Jianmin, Zhang, Ping
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Collocation; Correlation coefficient; Correlation coefficients; Data assimilation; Data collection; Error analysis; Ground-based observation; Hydrometeorology; In situ measurement; Microwave radiometers; Quality assessment; Radiometers; Remote regions; Satellites; Snow accumulation; Snow depth; Surface roughness; Temperate climates; Uncertainty
• ISSN: 0043-1397; 1944-7973
• DOI: 10.1029/2021WR030895

The optimal use of hemispheric‐scale snow depth (SD) products for various hydrometeorological applications requires a comprehensive assessment of their quality. Most previous validation studies of SD products adopted in situ observations as the ground truth, which may cause representativeness errors due to spatial scale mismatch between point‐based ground SD measurements and grid‐based SD products. The extended triple collocation (ETC) technique is a powerful tool to estimate the uncertainty of three independent data sets without assuming any one data source is an error‐free “truth” reference. This study first used the ETC to assess the uncertainty of three types of hemispheric‐scale SD products, including the ground‐based analysis Canadian Meteorological Centre (CMC), the satellite‐based Advanced Microwave Scanning Radiometer 2 (AMSR2), and the model‐based Global Land Data Assimilation System (GLDAS) SD products. Furthermore, the uncertainties of each SD product were analyzed using ETC metrics, that is, the correlation coefficient (R) and error standard deviations (STDs), with respect to several environmental and perturbing factors. Overall, the CMC outperforms the AMSR2 and GLDAS, with a higher R and a smaller STD. Considering multiple environmental and perturbing factors, the poorest performance of the three SD products is mainly found in densely vegetated regions, and they are strongly related to the forest cover fraction and surface roughness. Despite the above factors, the best performance for all three SD products is found over temperate climate regions. The results demonstrate the usefulness of the ETC approach to quantify the uncertainty of SD products particularly in remote regions with sparse in situ measurements. Key Points The ground‐based analysis Canadian Meteorological Centre product generally performs the best among three snow depth products in the northern hemisphere The skill of three snow depth products is significantly affected by forest cover fraction and surface roughness