On the Ontological Status of Mechanisms and Processes in the Social World

• Published in: Foundations of science 2022-09, Vol.27 (3), p.987-1000
• Main Author: Delgado, Henrique Estides
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Book publishing; Cognitive ability; Education; Mathematical Logic and Foundations; Methodology of the Social Sciences; Ontology; Philosophy; Philosophy of Science; Social sciences; Tilly, Charles
• ISSN: 1233-1821; 1572-8471
• DOI: 10.1007/s10699-021-09787-0

This paper gives a philosophical outline of the importance of plausible ontologies in the social sciences and argues how mechanisms and processes should be placed as the foundation in the social world. The argumentation is mainly based on a critical appraisal of the use of mechanisms and processes in the works of Norbert Elias, Charles Tilly, and Jon Elster. I start by elaborating on how inquiries of scientific interest evolve to shed light on cases, facts and the things that constitute such facts, whilst the actual explanation demands the description of mechanisms and processes. Basically, focusing on (co)variation and difference making is not sufficient to sustain claims of ontological plausibility and reasonableness. It is thus pointed out how the practices and proceedings of the social sciences can be ontologically enhanced by embracing the complementary roles of mechanisms plus processes together with difference making, as is performed in a special science such as biology, as well as is informally but promisingly pursued in the works of the discussed social scientists. While discussing their work, it is also argued that we should differentiate between processes and mechanisms in order to formalize this approach, which highlights the role of technologies and institutions as prime building blocks for social explanation. I conclude by presenting a claim that in taking seriously that the purported relations between beings and entities need to make discursive sense and historical sense, the social sciences will increase our cognitive success about the things of the world.