Proficiency test of pH, conductivity and dissolved oxygen concentration field measurements in river water

• Published in: Accreditation and quality assurance 2014-08, Vol.19 (4), p.259-268
• Main Authors: Näykki, Teemu, Leivuori, Mirja, Björklöf, Katarina, Väisänen, Ritva, Laine, Marko, Väisänen, Tero, Leito, Ivo
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Accreditation; Analytical Chemistry; Biochemistry; Chemical sensors; Chemistry; Chemistry and Materials Science; Commercial Law; Dissolved oxygen; Ecotoxicology; Food Science; Homogeneity; Laboratories; Luminescence quenching; Marketing; Oxygen content; Performance evaluation; Practitioner's Report; Quality assurance; Quality control; Sensors; Stability analysis; Variance analysis; Water analysis
• ISSN: 0949-1775; 1432-0517
• DOI: 10.1007/s00769-014-1064-5

In 2013, Proftest SYKE organised the first proficiency test (PT) in Finland for field measurements of temperature, conductivity, dissolved oxygen concentration, oxygen saturation and pH value in river water. The aim was to pilot the organisation of an in situ proficiency test—particularly, how to select the test location—and how to assess the homogeneity and stability of the measurement site and the water to be tested. The focus was also to evaluate the suitability of the common field sensors used for water analysis, as well as the comparability of the results between the instruments under field conditions. The overall application of quality assurance procedures was also surveyed. This paper deals with the results, findings and recommendations for the measurement of pH, conductivity and dissolved oxygen concentration. In total, nine participants with 16 sensors took part in the proficiency test. For the evaluation of the performance of each participant, z scores were calculated allowing 3 % to 8 % deviation from the assigned value. The standard deviation of the participant’s results was lower than organiser expected, and 80 % of the results for pH, 79 % for conductivity and 69 % for dissolved oxygen concentration were regarded as satisfactory. According to the results, the most challenging measurement was for dissolved oxygen with a Clark cell-type measurement principle based on electrochemical reaction. All sensors tested in the PT were less than 5 years, old and they were calibrated according to the manufacturer’s instructions. None of the participants had estimated measurement uncertainty for their sensor measurements. In addition, internal and external quality assurance protocols were usually lacking.