Aristotelian and Boolean Properties of the Keynes-Johnson Octagon of Opposition

• Published in: Journal of philosophical logic 2024-10, Vol.53 (5), p.1265-1290
• Main Authors: Demey, Lorenz, Smessaert, Hans
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Boolean; Education; Logic; Negation; Philosophy
• ISSN: 0022-3611; 1573-0433
• DOI: 10.1007/s10992-024-09765-4

Around the turn of the 20th century, Keynes and Johnson extended the well-known square of opposition to an octagon of opposition, in order to account for subject negation (e.g., statements like ‘all non- S are P ’). The main goal of this paper is to study the logical properties of the Keynes-Johnson (KJ) octagons of opposition. In particular, we will discuss three concrete examples of KJ octagons: the original one for subject-negation, a contemporary one from knowledge representation, and a third one (hitherto not yet studied) from deontic logic. We show that these three KJ octagons are all Aristotelian isomorphic, but not all Boolean isomorphic to each other (the first two are representable by bitstrings of length 7, whereas the third one is representable by bitstrings of length 6). These results nicely fit within our ongoing research efforts toward setting up a systematic classification of squares, octagons, and other diagrams of opposition. Finally, obtaining a better theoretical understanding of the KJ octagons allows us to answer some open questions that have arisen in recent applications of these diagrams.