Evidence for low viscosity garnet-rich layers in the upper mantle

• Published in: Earth and planetary science letters 2010-01, Vol.289 (1), p.54-67
• Main Authors: Barnhoorn, Auke, Drury, Martyn R., van Roermund, Herman L.M.
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Creep (materials); Diffusion; diffusion creep; Diffusion layers; Garnets; Mantle; microstructures; Olivine; peridotite; rheology; Rocks; strength contrast; ultra-high pressure metamorphism; Viscosity
• ISSN: 0012-821X; 1385-013X
• DOI: 10.1016/j.epsl.2009.10.028

The rheological properties of upper mantle rocks play an important role in controlling the dynamics of the lithosphere and mantle convection. Experimental studies and microstructures in naturally deformed mantle rocks usually imply that olivine controls the upper mantle rheology. Here we show for the first time evidence from the geometry of folded compositional layers in mantle rocks from Western Norway that garnet-rich rocks can have lower solid-state viscosities than olivine-rich rocks. Modeling of melt-free and dry rheology of garnet and olivine confirms that the reversed viscosity contrast between garnet-rich and olivine-rich layers for this folding event can be achieved over a relatively wide range of temperatures at low stress conditions when the fine-grained garnet deforms by diffusion creep while the coarse-grained olivine deforms by dislocation creep and/or diffusion creep. In general, modeling of the fold viscosity contrast shows that in the stable subcontinental lithospheric mantle or convecting mantle such a reversed viscosity contrast can be formed due to diffusion creep processes in fine-grained garnets in a dry mantle environment or at conditions where the garnet-pyroxene layer is partially molten, i.e. close to solidus–liquidus conditions in the upper mantle. Alternatively in cold plate tectonic settings, e.g. in subduction zones, some water-weakening is a feasible mechanism to create the reversed viscosity contrast between garnet and olivine.