Solution of forest health problems with prescribed fire: are forest productivity and wildlife at risk?

• Published in: Forest ecology and management 2000-03, Vol.127 (1), p.1-18
• Main Authors: Tiedemann, Arthur R., O. Klemmedson, James, Bull, Evelyn L.
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Animal and plant ecology; Animal, plant and microbial ecology; Biological and medical sciences; Biomass; botanical composition; dead wood; Decomposition; degradation; Down wood; ecological succession; economic analysis; fire effects; fires; forest fires; Forest floor; forest management; Forest management. Stand types and stand dynamics. Silvicultural treatments. Tending of stands. Natural regeneration; forest soils; Forestry; forests; Fuels; Fundamental and applied biological sciences. Psychology; Larix occidentalis; literature reviews; logs; Nutrients (soil and biomass); Pinus ponderosa; plant diseases and disorders; plant pests; prescribed burning; risk assessment; Snags; stand density; Stand types and stand dynamics. Silvicultural treatments. Tending of stands. Natural regeneration; Synecology; Terrestrial ecosystems; volume; wildlife
• ISSN: 0378-1127; 1872-7042
• DOI: 10.1016/S0378-1127(99)00114-0

Advanced forest succession and associated accumulations of forest biomass in the Blue Mountains of Oregon and Washington and Intermountain area have led to increased vulnerability of these forests to insects, diseases, and wildfire. One proposed solution is large-scale conversion of these forests to seral conditions that emulate those assumed to exist before European settlement: open-spaced stands (ca. 50 trees per ha), consisting primarily of ponderosa pine ( Pinus ponderosa Laws.) and western larch ( Larix occidentalis Nutt.). We question how well presettlement forest conditions are understood and the feasibility and desirability of conversion to a seral state that represents those conditions. Current and future expectations of forest outputs and values are far different from those at presettlement times. Emphasis on prescribed fire for achieving and maintaining this conversion raises questions about how well we understand fire effects on forest resources and values. We consider here potential effects of prescribed fire on two key aspects of forest management—productivity and wildlife. Use of large-scale prescribed fire presents complex problems with potential long-term effects on forest resources. Before implementing prescribed fire widely, we need to understand the range of its effects on all resources and values. Rather than attempting to convert forests to poorly described and understood presettlement seral conditions, it would seem prudent to examine present forest conditions and assess their potential to provide desired resource outputs and values. Once this is achieved, the full complement of forest management tools and strategies, including prescribed fire, should be used to accomplish the desired objectives. We suggest a more conservative approach until prescribed fire effects are better understood.