Experimental considerations in metal mobilization from soil by chelating ligands: The influence of soil-solution ratio and pre-equilibration – A case study on Fe acquisition by phytosiderophores

• Published in: The Science of the total environment 2017-02, Vol.579, p.1831-1842
• Main Authors: Schenkeveld, W.D.C., Kimber, R.L., Walter, M., Oburger, E., Puschenreiter, M., Kraemer, S.M.
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Chelating agent; Fe acquisition; Metal mobilization; Phytosiderophore; Pre-equilibration; Soil solution ratio (SSR)
• ISSN: 0048-9697; 1879-1026
• DOI: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2016.11.168

The efficiency of chelating ligands in mobilizing metals from soils and sediments is generally examined under conditions remote from those under which they are exuded or applied in the field. This may lead to incorrect estimations of the mobilizing efficiency. The aim of this study was to establish the influence of the soil solution ratio (SSR) and pre-equilibration with electrolyte solution on metal mobilization and metal displacement. For this purpose a series of interaction experiments with a calcareous clay soil and a biogenic chelating agent, the phytosiderophore 2′-deoxymugineic acid (DMA) were carried out. For a fixed ligand concentration, the SSR had a strong influence on metal mobilization and displacement. Metal complexation was faster at higher SSR. Reactive pools of metals that were predominantly mobilized at SSR 6 (in this case Cu), became depleted at SSR 0.1, whereas metals that were marginally mobilized at SSR 6, were dominantly mobilized at SSR 0.1 (in this case Fe), because of large soil reactive pools. For a fixed “amount of ligand”-to-“amount of soil”-ratio, metal complexation scaled linearly with the SSR. The efficiency of ligands in mobilizing metals under field conditions can be predicted with batch experiments, as long as the ligand-to-soil-ratio is matched. In most previously reported studies this criterion was not met. Equivalent metal-complex concentrations under field conditions can be back-calculated using adsorption isotherms for the respective metal-complexes. Drying and dry storage created labile pools of Fe, Cu and Zn, which were rapidly mobilized upon addition of DMA solution to dry soil. Pre-equilibration decreased these labile pools, leading to smaller concentrations of these metals during initial mobilization, but did not reduce the lag time between ligand addition and onset of microbial degradation of the metal-complexes. Hence SSR and pre-equilibration should be carefully considered when testing the metal mobilizing efficiency of chelating ligands. [Display omitted] •Metal mobilizing efficiency of chelators is often tested under non-field-like conditions.•Soil solution ratio (SSR) strongly affects metal mobilization by chelators.•For a fixed ligand to soil ratio, metal complexation scales linearly with SSR.•Soil drying generates labile metal pools that are rapidly mobilized by chelators.•Pre-equilibration reduces the size of drying-related labile metal pools.