Vanishing Syria: Periodization and Power in Early Islam

• Published in: Der Islam (Berlin) 2014, Vol.91 (1), p.37-68
• Main Author: Borrut, Antoine
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Abbasids; Early modern history; Historiography; History of civilization; Islam; Islam and politics; Islamic civilization; Islamization; periodization; Syria; Umayyads
• ISSN: 0021-1818; 1613-0928
• DOI: 10.1515/islam-2014-0004

This article argues that the agreed-upon periodization of early Islam is an Abbasid-era construct that became a binding framework for later generations of historians down to modern times. It also contends that scholars have tended to ignore the fact that this periodization was first and foremost an Abbasid claim to power. It investigates the Abbasid-era construction of the past and demonstrates that alternative periodizations were used prior to these massive efforts to enclose the past into a rigid structure, and so it sheds light on forgotten alternative pasts. The links between periodization and space are emphasized, focusing on the example of early Islamic Syria. Indeed, this province largely vanished from the map with the coming of the Abbasids to power since Syria’s memory came to be limited to its Umayyad past. Elaborating upon alternative periodizations, the paper offers a fresh attempt at a history of the meanings ( ) of a long Syrian eighth century, articulated around memory and power.