Bird Tolerance to Human Intrusion in Wyoming Montane Forests

• Published in: The Condor (Los Angeles, Calif.) Calif.), 1998-08, Vol.100 (3), p.519-527
• Main Authors: Gutzwiller, Kevin J., Marcum, Heidi A., Harvey, Henry B., Roth, James D., Anderson, Stanley H.
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Animal and plant ecology; Animal, plant and microbial ecology; Animals; Autoecology; Aves; Aviculture; Biological and medical sciences; Bird nesting; Birds; Breeding seasons; Environmental impact; Forests; Fundamental and applied biological sciences. Psychology; Humans; Montane forests; Mountain forests; Ornithology; Passeriformes; Species; USA, Wyoming; Vegetation; Vertebrata; Waterfowl; Wildlife management
• ISSN: 0010-5422; 1938-5129; 2732-4621
• DOI: 10.2307/1369718

Human intrusion can be a serious problem for birds because it can cause displacement, prevent access to resources, and reduce reproduction and survival. The factors that influence avian tolerance to intrusion are poorly understood. We studied passerine responses to intrusion in Wyoming montane forests during the breeding season by using two indices of intrusion tolerance: detectability period, the amount of time that a bird remains near its initial flush point; and approach distance, how close one can get to a bird before it flushes. A solitary observer experimentally approached focal individuals and recorded detectability period, approach distance, the seasonal and daily timing of intrusion, number of nearby conspecifics, number of nearby heterospecific individuals, and surrounding vegetation conditions. Using data from the literature, we also assessed influences of migratory status, body mass, conspicuousness, and height above the ground at which species are active during the breeding season. Detectability period was significantly shorter, indicating intrusion tolerance was lower, when fewer conspecifics were nearby. Approach distance was significantly longer, indicating tolerance was lower, for more-conspicuous species and for species that are active closer to the ground. Effects of other variables studied were not significant. These results demonstrate that social and biological factors can influence tolerance to intrusion. Intrusion-induced behaviors such as nest abandonment and decreased nest attentiveness have led to reduced reproduction and survival in species that are intolerant of intrusion. With knowledge of factors that influence tolerance, the risk of disturbing birds that are sensitive to intrusion could be reduced.