Detecting substance-related problems in narrative investigation summaries of child abuse and neglect using text mining and machine learning

• Published in: Child abuse & neglect 2019-12, Vol.98, p.104180-104180, Article 104180
• Main Authors: Perron, Brian E., Victor, Bryan G., Bushman, Gregory, Moore, Andrew, Ryan, Joseph P., Lu, Alex Jiahong, Piellusch, Emily K.
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Child Abuse; Child abuse & neglect; Child Neglect; Child welfare; Children; Coding; Computers; Cost analysis; Data; Data mining; Data science; Feasibility; Government agencies; Machine learning; Substance abuse; Substance misuse; Text classification; Text mining; Welfare Services; Welfare state
• ISSN: 0145-2134; 1873-7757
• DOI: 10.1016/j.chiabu.2019.104180

State child welfare agencies collect, store, and manage vast amounts of data. However, they often do not have the right data, or the data is problematic or difficult to inform strategies to improve services and system processes. Considerable resources are required to read and code these text data. Data science and text mining offer potentially efficient and cost-effective strategies for maximizing the value of these data. The current study tests the feasibility of using text mining for extracting information from unstructured text to better understand substance-related problems among families investigated for abuse or neglect. A state child welfare agency provided written summaries from investigations of child abuse and neglect. Expert human reviewers coded 2956 investigation summaries based on whether the caseworker observed a substance-related problem. These coded documents were used to develop, train, and validate computer models that could perform the coding on an automated basis. A set of computer models achieved greater than 90% accuracy when judged against expert human reviewers. Fleiss kappa estimates among computer models and expert human reviewers exceeded .80, indicating that expert human reviewer ratings are exchangeable with the computer models. These results provide compelling evidence that text mining procedures can be a cost-effective and efficient solution for extracting meaningful insights from unstructured text data. Additional research is necessary to understand how to extract the actionable insights from these under-utilized stores of data in child welfare.