Breaking bad news about glaucoma: a SPIKES strategy primer

• Published in: International ophthalmology 2021-12, Vol.41 (12), p.3893-3901
• Main Authors: Ichhpujani, Parul, Kalra, Gagan, Singla, Ekta, Kumar, Suresh
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Diagnosis; Glaucoma; Medical personnel; Medicine; Medicine & Public Health; News; Ophthalmology; Original Paper; Patients; Physicians; Polls & surveys; Privacy; Terminology; Visual perception
• ISSN: 0165-5701; 1573-2630
• DOI: 10.1007/s10792-021-01956-1

Purpose Most ophthalmic physicians are not formally trained for breaking the news of having sight threatening diseases, requiring lifelong therapy. This study aims to ascertain physician practices and patients’ experiences regarding delivery of bad news. Methods An online, anonymous questionnaire was sent to 400 ophthalmologists practising glaucoma to gather information as to how they deliver bad news to their patients. A parallel survey was also conducted amongst 100 established glaucoma patients to know whether how their doctor had delivered the diagnosis of glaucoma to them. After this, resident doctors were trained in SPIKES strategy and the patient survey was repeated in 100 new patients. Results Two hundred and eighteen out of 400 ophthalmologists responded to our survey resulting in a survey yield of 54.5%. About 56.5% ophthalmologists dealt with disclosing the diagnosis >20 times a month; 70% of responders always discussed about the true severity of disease up-front. Only 8.70% respondents had formal training for breaking the bad news. Results of first phase of patient survey revealed that nearly one-third of patients (27%), felt that their doctor used incomprehensible medical terminology and 42% patients said that their doctor downplayed their diagnosis. Only 12% provided information to their patients about reliable sources to gather additional information. After the resident doctors were trained in SPIKES strategy, the second phase of patient survey had marked positive change in the way information was delivered. Conclusion The current study shows that despite years of clinical experience, many ophthalmologists face difficulty in delivering bad news for a sight threatening disease such as glaucoma. Therefore, SPIKES strategy or a similar protocol must be taught to practising ophthalmologists at all levels, to alleviate worries of patients suffering from chronic, visually debilitating diseases.