Model-as-replica, model-as-instrument: Representational power and contextual versatility in animal models

• Published in: Studies in history and philosophy of science. Part A 2021-10, Vol.89, p.19-30
• Main Author: Polat, Bican
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Animal models; Animals; Behavioral neuroscience; Cardiovascular disease; Case studies; Circadian rhythm; Context; Experimental system; Heart rate; Infants; Instrumentation; Laboratory animals; Modeling practices; Mother-offspring interactions; Myocardial infarction; Organisms; Power; R&D; Representational power; Research & development; Research organisms; Resting; Rhythm; Serendipity; Sleep and wakefulness; Stimulus; Susceptibility; Transformation; Versatility
• ISSN: 0039-3681; 1879-2510
• DOI: 10.1016/j.shpsa.2021.07.003

Existing scholarship on animal models tends to foreground either of the two major roles research organisms play in different epistemic contexts, treating their representational and instrumental roles separately. Based on an empirical case study, this article explores the changing relationship between the two epistemic roles of a research organism over the span of a decade, while the organism was used to achieve various knowledge ends. This rat model was originally intended as a replica of human susceptibility to cardiac arrest. In a fortunate stroke of serendipity, however, the experimenters detected the way mother-infant interactions regulated the pups’ resting cardiac rate. This intriguing outcome thus became the model’s new representational target and began driving the development of an experimental system. Henceforth, the model acquired an instrumental function, serving to detect and measure system-specific differences. Its subsequent development involved creating stimulus-response measures to explain and theorize those differences. It was this instrumental use of the model that pushed the experimenters into unchartered territory and conferred to the model an ability to adapt to varied epistemic contexts. Despite the prominence of this instrumental role, however, the model’s representational power continued to guide research. The model’s representational target was widened beyond heart rate to reflect other functional phenomena, such as behavioral activity and sleep/wake rhythm. The rat model was thus transformed from an experimental organism designed to instantiate cardiac regulation to a model organism taken to represent the development of a whole, intact animal under the regulatory influence of maternal care. This article examines this multifaceted transformation within the context of the salient shifts in modeling practice and variations in the model’s representational power. It thus explores how the relationship between the representational and instrumental uses of the model changed with respect to the varying exigencies of the investigative context, foregrounding its contextual versatility.