Development of a national health policy logic model to accelerate the integration of oncology and palliative care: a nationwide Delphi survey in Japan

• Published in: International journal of clinical oncology 2022-09, Vol.27 (9), p.1529-1542
• Main Authors: Uneno, Yu, Iwai, Maki, Morikawa, Naoto, Tagami, Keita, Matsumoto, Yoko, Nozato, Junko, Kessoku, Takaomi, Shimoi, Tatsunori, Yoshida, Miyuki, Miyoshi, Aya, Sugiyama, Ikuko, Mantani, Kazuhiro, Itagaki, Mai, Yamagishi, Akemi, Morita, Tatsuya, Inoue, Akira, Muto, Manabu
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Cancer; Cancer Research; Control programs; Hospitals; Medicine; Medicine & Public Health; Oncology; Original Article; Palliation; Palliative care; Proposals; Surgical Oncology; Surveys
• ISSN: 1341-9625; 1437-7772
• DOI: 10.1007/s10147-022-02201-0

Background Despite recommendations to deliver palliative care to cancer patients and their caregivers, their distress has not been alleviated satisfactorily. National health policies play a pivotal role in achieving a comprehensive range of quality palliative care delivery for the public. However, there is no standardised logic model to appraise the efficacy of these policies. This study aimed to develop a logic model of a national health policy to deliver cancer palliative care and to reach consensus towards specific policy proposals. Methods A draft version of the logic model and specific policy proposals were formulated by the research team and the internal expert panel, and the independent external expert panel evaluated the policy proposals based on the Delphi survey to reach consensus. Results The logic model was divided into three major conceptual categories: ‘care-delivery at cancer hospitals’, ‘community care coordination’, and ‘social awareness of palliative care’. There were 18 and 45 major and minor policy proposals, which were categorised into four groups: requirement of government-designated cancer hospitals; financial support; Basic Plan to Promote Cancer Control Programs; and others. These policy proposals were independently evaluated by 64 external experts and the first to third Delphi round response rates were 96.9–98.4%. Finally, 47 policy proposals reached consensus. The priority of each proposal was evaluated within the four policy groups. Conclusions A national health policy logic model was developed to accelerate the provision of cancer palliative care. Further research is warranted to verify the study design to investigate the efficacy of the logic model.