Multi-response Mendelian randomization: Identification of shared and distinct exposures for multimorbidity and multiple related disease outcomes

• Published in: American journal of human genetics 2023-07, Vol.110 (7), p.1177-1199
• Main Authors: Zuber, Verena, Lewin, Alex, Levin, Michael G., Haglund, Alexander, Ben-Aicha, Soumaya, Emanueli, Costanza, Damrauer, Scott, Burgess, Stephen, Gill, Dipender, Bottolo, Leonardo
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Bayes Theorem; Cardiovascular Diseases - epidemiology; Cardiovascular Diseases - genetics; causal inference; Causality; Gaussian copula regression; Genome-Wide Association Study; Humans; instrumental variable; Mendelian randomization; Mendelian Randomization Analysis - methods; multi-trait models; Multimorbidity
• ISSN: 0002-9297; 1537-6605
• DOI: 10.1016/j.ajhg.2023.06.005

The existing framework of Mendelian randomization (MR) infers the causal effect of one or multiple exposures on one single outcome. It is not designed to jointly model multiple outcomes, as would be necessary to detect causes of more than one outcome and would be relevant to model multimorbidity or other related disease outcomes. Here, we introduce multi-response Mendelian randomization (MR2), an MR method specifically designed for multiple outcomes to identify exposures that cause more than one outcome or, conversely, exposures that exert their effect on distinct responses. MR2 uses a sparse Bayesian Gaussian copula regression framework to detect causal effects while estimating the residual correlation between summary-level outcomes, i.e., the correlation that cannot be explained by the exposures, and vice versa. We show both theoretically and in a comprehensive simulation study how unmeasured shared pleiotropy induces residual correlation between outcomes irrespective of sample overlap. We also reveal how non-genetic factors that affect more than one outcome contribute to their correlation. We demonstrate that by accounting for residual correlation, MR2 has higher power to detect shared exposures causing more than one outcome. It also provides more accurate causal effect estimates than existing methods that ignore the dependence between related responses. Finally, we illustrate how MR2 detects shared and distinct causal exposures for five cardiovascular diseases in two applications considering cardiometabolic and lipidomic exposures and uncovers residual correlation between summary-level outcomes reflecting known relationships between cardiovascular diseases. Existing Mendelian randomization (MR) models consider one outcome at a time in isolation and cannot identify causes of multimorbidity. We present multi-response MR (MR2), an MR method specifically designed for multiple outcomes to identify exposures that cause multiple responses or, conversely, exposures that exert their effect on distinct responses.