Net Effects Explains the Benefits to Children from Maternal Fish Consumption Despite Methylmercury in Fish

• Published in: Neurotoxicology (Park Forest South) 2023-12, Vol.99, p.195-205
• Main Authors: Spiller, Philip, van Wijngaarden, Edwin, Adams, Heather R., Strain, J.J., McSorley, Emeir M., Mulhern, Maria S., Conway, Marie C., Yeates, Allison J., Carrington, Clark, Bolger, P. Michael, Morgan, Kara M., Taylor, Caroline M., Ralston, Nicholas V.C., Crawford, Michael A., Hibbeln, Joseph R., Brenna, J. Thomas, Myers, Gary J.
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: fish; methylmercury; net effects; neurodevelopment; omega-3; pregnancy
• ISSN: 0161-813X; 1872-9711
• DOI: 10.1016/j.neuro.2023.10.010

In 2001 the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) issued precautionary advice to pregnant women to limit fish consumption over concerns that the methylmercury content might harm their children’s neurodevelopment. This concern was based largely on results from an epidemiological study of mothers primarily exposed to methylmercury from consuming pilot whale. Subsequently, FDA and the World Health Organization/Food and Agriculture Organization (WHO/FAO) undertook independent assessments of fish consumption that considered net effects from both fish nutrients, primarily omega-3 fatty acids, as beneficial and methylmercury as harmful. Both assessments estimated that when mothers regularly consume fish during pregnancy, their children are likely to have improved neurodevelopment compared to children of non-fish eaters despite their exposure to methylmercury. These estimated improvements included gains of two to over five full scale IQ points from levels of maternal consumption that are achievable in most of the world. Consistent with those estimates, human research on fish consumption and child neurodevelopment from more than 200,000 mother-child pairs now collectively reports 51 beneficial associations with neurodevelopmental outcomes and three adverse associations, the latter with no discernable pattern. These associations include full scale IQ gains similar to, or somewhat higher than, those estimated by FDA and FAO/WHO. Also consistent with the FDA and FAO/WHO estimates, research has reported beneficial associations with fish consumption when pregnant women are exposed to methylmercury from fish in excess of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s (EPA) Reference Dose (RfD). Our analysis evaluates how the net effects approach as utilized by FDA and FAO/WHO provides a holistic explanation for these results with implications for public health policy. This concordance of net effects modeling and empirical scientific evidence supports a clarification of current public health recommendations to focus on greater fish consumption by pregnant women for their children’s neurodevelopment.