Penetrance, variable expressivity and monogenic neurodevelopmental disorders

• Published in: European journal of medical genetics 2024-06, Vol.69, p.104932-104932, Article 104932
• Main Authors: de Masfrand, Servane, Cogné, Benjamin, Nizon, Mathilde, Deb, Wallid, Goldenberg, Alice, Lecoquierre, François, Nicolas, Gaël, Bournez, Marie, Vitobello, Antonio, Mau-Them, Frédéric Tran, le Guyader, Gwenaël, Bilan, Frédéric, Bauer, Peter, Zweier, Christiane, Piard, Juliette, Pasquier, Laurent, Bézieau, Stéphane, Gerard, Bénédicte, Faivre, Laurence, Saugier-Veber, Pascale, Piton, Amélie, Isidor, Bertrand
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Adolescent; Adult; Child; Child, Preschool; Female; Humans; Incomplete penetrance; Infant; Intellectual disability; Male; Monogenic; Mutation; Neurodevelopmental disorder; Neurodevelopmental Disorders - genetics; Neurodevelopmental Disorders - pathology; Pedigree; Penetrance
• ISSN: 1769-7212; 1878-0849
• DOI: 10.1016/j.ejmg.2024.104932

Incomplete penetrance is observed for most monogenic diseases. However, for neurodevelopmental disorders, the interpretation of single and multi-nucleotide variants (SNV/MNVs) is usually based on the paradigm of complete penetrance. From 2020 to 2022, we proposed a collaboration study with the French molecular diagnosis for intellectual disability network. The aim was to recruit families for whom the index case, diagnosed with a neurodevelopmental disorder, was carrying a pathogenic or likely pathogenic variant for an OMIM morbid gene and inherited from an asymptomatic parent. Grandparents were analyzed when available for segregation study. We identified 12 patients affected by a monogenic neurodevelopmental disorder caused by likely pathogenic or pathogenic variant (SNV/MNV) inherited from an asymptomatic parent. These genes were usually associated with de novo variants. The patients carried different variants (1 splice-site variant, 4 nonsense and 7 frameshift) in 11 genes: CAMTA1, MBD5, KMT2C, KMT2E, ZMIZ1, MN1, NDUFB11, CUL3, MED13, ARID2 and RERE. Grandparents have been tested in 6 families, and each time the variant was confirmed de novo in the healthy carrier parent. Incomplete penetrance for SNV and MNV in neurodevelopmental disorders might be more frequent than previously thought. This point is crucial to consider for interpretation of variants, family investigation, genetic counseling, and prenatal diagnosis. Molecular mechanisms underlying this incomplete penetrance still need to be identified.