Parental regret following decision for sons to undergo elective post-neonatal circumcision

• Published in: Journal of pediatric urology 2024-10
• Main Authors: Bashi, Tomer, Rorman, Hadas, Savin, Ziv, Bar-Yaakov, Noam, Dekalo, Snir, Ben-Chaim, Jacob, Bar-Yosef, Yuval
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Circumcision; Parents; Regret
• ISSN: 1477-5131; 1873-4898; 1873-4898
• DOI: 10.1016/j.jpurol.2024.10.005

The reasons for performing a circumcision among males after the neonatal period are usually cultural or medical. We aimed to evaluate parental regret for providing consent and to identify factors associated with such regret. Included were the parents of males aged 6 months to 18 years who underwent circumcision under general anesthesia at a single center between 2/2017 and 01/2023. Those who underwent additional surgical procedures during the same session were excluded. Parents responded telephonically to the Decision Regret Scale (DRS) questionnaire. Regret was classified as none (0 points), mild (1–25) or moderate-to-strong (26–100). Surgical and demographic data were retrieved for comparison to DRS scores and identification of predictors of parental regret. In total, 201 of the 265 suitable patients met the inclusion criteria. Parents of 130 patients (65% response rate) whose average age was 5.06 (IQR 1.58,7.53) years completed the DRS questionnaire (study group). The average time since surgery was 41.8 (IQR 25.4,59.3) months. Forty surgeries were undertaken for cultural reasons and 90 for medical considerations. Eighteen parents reported regret (15 mild and 3 moderate-to-strong) for their decision to consent to their son's circumcision. The time from responding since surgery was the only significant variable in the DRS scores, with a 33-month gap predicting no regret (p = 0.02 compared to shorter gaps). The reasons for circumcision did not significantly differ between the "regret" and "no-regret" groups (p = 0.23). Our current investigation revealed a lower incidence of parental regret when compared to previous reports following distal hypospadias repair, likely attributable to the lower complication rate associated with circumcision. Our data reflect the experience of a single center in a country where neonatal male circumcision is routinely performed for cultural and religious reasons, thus precluding the generalization of our findings to places where post-natal circumcision is less commonplace. Consent to their son's post-neonatal circumcision was regretted by 13.8% of parents. Time since surgery significantly influenced the reduction of their negative attitudes.Summary TableClinical characteristics of the study cohort stratified by parental decisional regret (n = 130)Summary tableVariableNo decisional regret (n = 112)Decisional regret (n = 18)p-valueaAge, years (median [IQR])4.85 (1.59,7.41)6.37 (1.61,9.9)0.15Cultural reason35/40 (87.5%)5/40 (12.5%