Understanding the context of positive experiences of primary care for transgender and gender diverse adults: An email interview study in Aotearoa New Zealand

• Published in: International journal of transgender health 2024-10, Vol.25 (4), p.704-718
• Main Authors: Withey-Rila, Cassie, Morgaine, Kate C, Treharne, Gareth J
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Non-binary gender; Primary care; Transgender persons
• ISSN: 2689-5269; 2689-5277; 2689-5277
• DOI: 10.1080/26895269.2023.2234899

Past research has demonstrated that transgender and gender diverse (TGD) people often have negative experiences of healthcare. Exploratory research is needed to provide in-depth understanding of the healthcare experiences of TGD people. Primary care is a crucial element of healthcare, but past research has tended to overlook what contributes specifically to positive experiences of primary care for TGD adults. The aim of this study was to explore positive experiences of TGD adults when engaging with primary care in Aotearoa New Zealand. Semi-structured email interviews were conducted with 11 TGD adults aged 20- to 62-years-old, with a range of binary or non-binary genders living across Aotearoa New Zealand. The email interview method allowed nationwide recruitment and flexible interaction. All aspects of the study were led by a researcher who is part of the TGD community. Three themes were formulated to explain TGD participants' positive experiences with primary care. In order to contextualize positive experiences, participants described past negative experiences of healthcare and low expectations (Theme 1: The Sad State of Care). Participants also described exerting autonomy, for example by carefully selecting a general practitioner (GP) or choosing when to disclose transgender status to their GP (Theme 2: The Sphere of Control). Three levels were evident in positive experiences (Theme 3: The Gradient of Positive Experiences): basic professionalism, more desirable experiences of trans-specific competencies, and GPs as advocates for systemic change. TGD people experience positive interactions in primary care in a variety of ways, all of which are contextualized by the negative state of healthcare at present. TGD people create opportunity for autonomy while navigating healthcare, which requires a form of interacting that can be termed reactive self-determination. Training for health professionals could apply the gradient of positive experiences to scaffold appropriate primary care for TGD adults.