Ligands Raise the Constraint That Limits Constitutive Activation in G Protein-coupled Opioid Receptors

• Published in: The Journal of biological chemistry 2013-08, Vol.288 (33), p.23964-23978
• Main Authors: Vezzi, Vanessa, Onaran, H. Ongun, Molinari, Paola, Guerrini, Remo, Balboni, Gianfranco, Calò, Girolamo, Costa, Tommaso
• Format: Article
• Language: English
• Subjects: Arrestins - metabolism; beta-Arrestins; Bioluminescence Resonance Energy Transfer (BRET); Cell Line, Tumor; Computer Simulation; Constitutive Receptor Activation; Cooperativity; Drug Inverse Agonism; G Protein-coupled Receptors (GPCR); G Proteins; GTP-Binding Proteins - metabolism; Guanosine Diphosphate - metabolism; Humans; Inverse Agonism; Ligands; Models, Biological; Opiate Opioid; Quinuclidines - chemistry; Quinuclidines - pharmacology; Receptors, Opioid, delta - agonists; Receptors, Opioid, delta - metabolism; Receptors, Opioid, mu - metabolism; Signal Transduction; Tyrosine - analogs & derivatives; Tyrosine - chemistry; Tyrosine - pharmacology
• ISSN: 0021-9258; 1083-351X
• DOI: 10.1074/jbc.M113.474452

Using a cell-free bioluminescence resonance energy transfer strategy we compared the levels of spontaneous and ligand-induced receptor-G protein coupling in δ (DOP) and μ (MOP) opioid receptors. In this assay GDP can suppress spontaneous coupling, thus allowing its quantification. The level of constitutive activity was 4–5 times greater at the DOP than at the MOP receptor. A series of opioid analogues with a common peptidomimetic scaffold displayed remarkable inversions of efficacy in the two receptors. Agonists that enhanced coupling above the low intrinsic level of the MOP receptor were inverse agonists in reducing the greater level of constitutive coupling of the DOP receptor. Yet the intrinsic activities of such ligands are identical when scaled over the GDP base line of both receptors. This pattern is in conflict with the predictions of the ternary complex model and the “two state” extensions. According to this theory, the order of spontaneous and ligand-induced coupling cannot be reversed if a shift of the equilibrium between active and inactive forms raises constitutive activation in one receptor type. We propose that constitutive activation results from a lessened intrinsic barrier that restrains spontaneous coupling. Any ligand, regardless of its efficacy, must enhance this constraint to stabilize the ligand-bound complexed form. Background: Native subtypes of G protein-coupled receptors (GPCR) show different levels of constitutive activation. Results: Using a BRET assay to detect receptor-G protein complexes, we find that constitutive activation causes a uniform reduction of the apparent efficacy of all ligands. Conclusion: An intramolecular energy barrier separates constitutive from ligand-regulated activation. Significance: The data suggest that GPCR activation involves both cooperative and anticooperative components.